How Can a Democratic-Controlled Congress Start Rebuilding Trust in the United States as a Development Partner?

November 16, 2026

Published On:

By:

Brian Frantz, former USAID Africa Bureau head and GAIA Trustee

The Trump administration’s assault on USAID and other foreign assistance agencies in 2025 did untold damage to the reputation of the United States as a trusted development partner, the consequences of which we have yet to fully experience.  Restoring our credibility as a trusted partner could take years, possibly even a generation.  But following the results of the 2026 midterm elections, there are several steps that a Democratic-controlled Congress could take to begin that arduous process.

  • Congress should use its oversight powers to ensure implementing partners whose contracts and grants with USAID were summarily canceled are paid for legitimate work completed on behalf of the United States government.  When the new Congress convenes in January 2027, it will have been almost two years since the administration began its “pause” on foreign assistance, and countless organizations are still waiting for payment for work that has gone unreimbursed.  GAIA is one of those; it is still owed approximately $125,000.  GAIA is fortunate to have a committed base of private donors that stepped up to cover the gap created by the administration’s unilateral cancellation of GAIA’s agreements with USAID.  Many organizations – particularly local organizations – were not so lucky and unfortunately did not survive.  The U.S. government should pay its bills on time, full stop.  
  • The shuttering of USAID resulted in a tremendous loss of human capacity to manage foreign assistance effectively.  Attracting high-quality personnel back into the U.S. government to do so again will likely require holding those responsible for improperly dismissing USAID staff accountable.  Of course, the experience of USAID personnel is just one example of the administration’s wide-scale attack on the civil service, which deserves significant attention from Congress.  Ultimately, Congress should seek to define what kind of civil service we want – non-partisan, professional, and meritocratic or politicized.
  • Congress can also use its oversight powers to make sure the administration spends appropriated foreign assistance funding according to its intent.  I remain highly skeptical of the administration’s commitment to spend foreign assistance resources as Congress intends.  For example, Congress will need to remain vigilant to ensure that appropriated resources for the Global Fund, Gavi Alliance, and other such directives are spent accordingly.  Information regarding implementation of the MOUs the administration has signed with several dozen countries under the America First Global Health strategy has been sparse, demanding focused oversight attention as well.  
  • Repairing our reputation with the partner-country officials, communities, and publics served by U.S. foreign assistance programs may be the most critical, but also most difficult, part of restoring trust in the United States as a credible development partner.  We quite literally tore up bilateral agreements, without providing any notice to our supposed “partner” countries and their people.  I do not believe much progress can be made while the current administration remains in office, but whatever foreign assistance structure is eventually put in place will need robust bipartisan support to withstand potential attacks like that unleashed on USAID in 2025.  In fact, I would argue that Congress should take the lead in designing a future structure – and not rely on the executive branch – with an aim of passing relevant legislation once a new administration comes into office in 2029.  That work can begin in earnest now among a committed, bipartisan group of members.

The midterm results probably don’t herald a new dawn for U.S. foreign assistance.  Congress’s to-do list is extremely long, limiting how much political attention foreign assistance is likely to get.  Even before the election, only 10% of U.S. representatives who supported PEPFAR at its creation – arguably one of the most successful U.S. foreign assistance programs ever – were still in office, highlighting how much education on U.S. foreign assistance will be needed with the new Congress.  And some long-standing Republican supporters of foreign assistance, such as Susan Collins (ME) in the Senate and Young Kim (CA) in the House, lost their races.  Nevertheless, there are meaningful steps the Democratic-controlled Congress can take over the next two years to at least begin to repair the damage to U.S. foreign assistance wrought by the Trump administration.

Brian Frantz is a Professor of Practice in International Studies at Indiana University, GAIA Board Trustee, and retired USAID Senior Foreign Service Officer.  During his USAID career, he served in East Timor, Rwanda, Malawi, Kenya (covering Somalia), and Washington, DC.  From late January 2025 until his separation in September, he was USAID’s Acting Assistant Administrator for Africa.

women carrying water pales